Volkswagen ID.3 vs MG MG4: which should you buy?

TL;DR

The Volkswagen ID.3 is a more refined and spacious electric vehicle, while the MG MG4 offers a sportier drive and better value for money. If you prioritise comfort and interior quality, go for the ID.3; if you want a fun drive and a lower price, choose the MG4.

Key facts

The ID.3 starts at around £30,000, while the MG4 is priced from £26,000. The ID.3 offers a maximum range of up to 340 miles, whereas the MG4 can reach approximately 281 miles. The ID.3 produces 201 bhp, while the MG4 has a spirited 201 bhp from its rear-wheel drive setup. The MG4 comes with a seven-year warranty compared to the ID.3’s three-year coverage.

Reliability head-to-head

Reliability is crucial when considering an electric vehicle. The Volkswagen ID.3 has a mixed reputation, with some owners reporting software glitches and battery management issues, but it generally maintains a good reliability score. The MG4 has faced criticism regarding build quality and reliability, but its longer warranty may provide peace of mind. Overall, the ID.3 appears to be the more reliable option based on owner feedback.

Real-world running costs

The MG4 has an edge in running costs due to its lower purchase price and competitive energy efficiency. The ID.3, while more expensive upfront, has a slightly better range, which could offset some running costs for longer journeys. Both vehicles benefit from lower electric charging costs compared to petrol or diesel cars, but the MG4’s longer warranty may save money on repairs. Overall, the MG4 is likely the more economical choice for budget-conscious drivers.

How they drive

The ID.3 offers a smooth and composed ride, making it ideal for long journeys. Its electric motor provides instant torque, resulting in quick acceleration and comfort. The MG4 is more engaging to drive, with a sportier feel and rear-wheel drive layout appealing to those who enjoy dynamic driving. The choice ultimately comes down to personal preference: comfort versus sportiness.

Tech and interior

The ID.3 features a spacious and well-designed interior with high-quality materials and a user-friendly infotainment system, though some users find the touch-sensitive controls frustrating. The MG4 offers a modern interior with a straightforward layout and a large touchscreen that is easy to navigate. Both vehicles come with advanced tech features, but the ID.3 edges ahead in overall build quality and refinement.

Resale and depreciation

The ID.3 has a stronger brand reputation and is likely to hold its value better than the MG4. However, the MG brand is gaining traction in the UK, which may help its resale value. Generally, electric vehicles depreciate slower than traditional cars, but the ID.3’s established reputation could make it more attractive for future buyers. If long-term value retention is a priority, the ID.3 may be the safer bet.

What people are asking

• How big is the ID3 compared to the MG4? The MG4 is slightly longer at 4.28 m compared to the ID.3’s 4.26 m, making it easier to manoeuvre in tight spaces.
• What are the common problems with the ID 3? Common issues include software glitches and battery management problems, though many owners report overall satisfaction.
• What is the difference between MG4 and EV3? The MG4 is a more recent model with improved technology and performance compared to the older EV3.
• Why is Volkswagen discontinuing the ID4? Volkswagen is focusing on refining its electric vehicle lineup, with the ID.3 being a key model in their strategy.

Owner sentiment

Feedback from owners suggests that while the ID.3 is praised for its comfort and spaciousness, some find its tech interface challenging. In contrast, MG4 owners appreciate its sporty driving dynamics and value for money, although there are concerns about build quality. Overall, both cars have loyal fan bases, but the ID.3 tends to attract those prioritising comfort and refinement.

The verdict: which should you buy?

If you are looking for a comfortable, spacious electric vehicle with a solid reputation, the Volkswagen ID.3 is the clear choice. It excels in build quality and driving comfort, making it ideal for longer journeys. However, if you seek a more engaging driving experience and better value for money, the MG MG4 is a compelling alternative. Your decision should be based on your priorities: comfort and reliability versus sportiness and affordability.