Hyundai i20 vs Toyota Yaris: which should you buy?

TL;DR

The Hyundai i20 provides a spacious interior and a diverse engine range, making it suitable for both city and longer drives. In contrast, the Toyota Yaris is known for its reliability and strong resale value, making it a wise long-term investment.

Key facts

The Hyundai i20 measures 4040 mm in length, making it 100 mm longer than the Toyota Yaris at 3940 mm. The Yaris offers a hybrid option, while the i20 focuses on traditional petrol engines. Both cars come with a range of safety features, but the Yaris often scores higher in crash tests. The i20 generally has lower insurance costs compared to the Yaris, making it a more budget-friendly option.

Reliability head-to-head

Toyota has a strong reputation for reliability, and the Yaris exemplifies this with minimal reported issues over years of ownership. While Hyundai has improved its reliability, it does not yet match Toyota’s track record. Common issues with the Yaris include electrical problems and occasional transmission concerns, whereas the i20 is noted for its engine performance and build quality.

Real-world running costs

The Hyundai i20 is typically more economical regarding fuel efficiency, especially with its 1.0-litre turbocharged engine, which balances power and economy well. The Yaris, particularly in its hybrid form, offers excellent fuel savings, appealing to those focused on running costs. Both cars are relatively affordable to insure, but the i20 often falls into a lower insurance group, making it a better choice for younger drivers or those on a tighter budget.

How they drive

The i20 is praised for its responsive steering and composed handling, making it enjoyable for urban driving. The Yaris provides a comfortable ride with a focus on stability, although some may find it less engaging than the i20. The hybrid variant of the Yaris offers a smooth and quiet driving experience, ideal for city commuting, while the i20’s petrol engines provide more excitement on the open road.

Tech and interior

Both the Hyundai i20 and Toyota Yaris feature modern tech, including touchscreen infotainment systems and smartphone integration. The i20 has a more visually appealing and user-friendly interface, along with features like wireless charging in higher trims. The Yaris, however, offers a more comprehensive safety suite, including advanced driver-assistance systems. Interior quality is good in both cars, but the i20 provides slightly more space and practicality, especially in the rear seats.

Resale and depreciation

The Toyota Yaris generally retains its value better than the Hyundai i20, largely due to Toyota’s reliability reputation and the Yaris’s popularity in the used car market. The i20 may depreciate faster, but it can be more affordable upfront, appealing to buyers who plan to keep their car for a shorter period. If long-term ownership is a priority, the Yaris is likely the better investment.

What people are asking

• Is the i20 bigger than the Yaris? Yes, the i20 is 100 mm longer than the Yaris.
• What are the disadvantages of the Hyundai i20? Some users report that the i20 can feel less refined than competitors, particularly regarding engine noise and ride comfort.
• Which one is more reliable, Toyota or Hyundai? Generally, Toyota has a better reputation for reliability compared to Hyundai.
• What is the most common problem with Toyota Yaris? Common issues include electrical problems and transmission concerns.

Owner sentiment

On forums and Reddit, many owners express satisfaction with both models, noting the i20’s spaciousness and the Yaris’s reliability. Some i20 owners appreciate its modern design and tech features, while Yaris owners often commend its fuel efficiency and low running costs. However, opinions vary on the driving experience, with some preferring the sportier feel of the i20 over the more subdued nature of the Yaris.

The verdict: which should you buy?

Your choice between the Hyundai i20 and Toyota Yaris will depend on your priorities. If you value a spacious interior, engaging driving dynamics, and lower initial costs, the Hyundai i20 is the better option. However, if reliability, resale value, and fuel efficiency are your top concerns, the Toyota Yaris is the clear winner. For most buyers, the Yaris presents a more compelling package, especially for those seeking a long-term investment.